Thursday, March 10, 2011

“The Insufficiency of Honesty”


Carter connects honesty and integrity by saying you they are not one in their own. You cant have integrity though unless you are honest. Honesty to him is not lying but integrity is 3 things. “The first criterion captures the idea that integrity requires a degree of moral reflectiveness. The second brings in the ideal of a person of integrity as steadfast, a quality that includes keeping one's commitments. The third reminds us that a person of integrity can be trusted.”

He links the to so that you must be honest to have integrity but its not the sole reason for integrity. He also talks about fake honesty or irrelevant honest which is when someone doesn’t particularly lie but the hold the truth from someone. Then there is what some people thing is right but others think is wrong this is why integrity is not only honesty. Some people thing abortion is ok and others think it is murder. So the truth is integrity is linked to honesty but is not only honesty.

5 comments:

  1. I really like how you said he links the honest part to integrity but it doesn't necessarily mean having integrity. I like that, it makes more sense in a way. A lot people think just because your honest you have integrity, but as carter goes on to say, there are a few more things one should have to be considered one of integrity.

    ReplyDelete
  2. John,

    I thought that what Carter wrote was really good because I hadn't given much thought to what integrity meant. I had a completely misconstrued idea of what it was. This article really helped clarify my understanding of integrity. I'm sure that it did the same for other people in the class.

    Maybe that's also why it's a virtue that's hard to possess because we don't even know what it really means. Ignorance often is the root of a lot of problems. It's good to be informed, it permits you to become a better person.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with your reasoning when you said that "Carter connects honesty and integrity by saying you are not one in their own. You cant have integrity unless you are honest." that statement is very true. To have integrity you need to be honest with yourself and if you cannot achieve this step then you're not even being true to yourself.

    ReplyDelete
  4. John,
    You hit on a really good point. It is much easier to trust someone who has integrity rather than just honesty. Someone who is just honest you might not trust in all situations but someone with integrity you can trust in any situation that presents itself to you. Thank you for your time John.

    ReplyDelete
  5. After reading Carters definition of integrity, I realize now that honesty at the expense of others while also benfeting yourself does not mean that you have integrity. Also, just because you think that something is right does not mean that it is. You are being honest of your beliefs but you should also take the time to research a little bit of the facts in order to support your beliefs.

    ReplyDelete